LA Fitness, Garden City Park, New York: A Month Closed by a Commissioner's Order
In December 2016 the Nassau County health commissioner ordered the pool and spa at the LA Fitness on Jericho Turnpike in Garden City Park closed after testing confirmed significant Legionella. A month later there was still no reopening date — the county would lift the order only when the club proved the pool met its criteria.
Garden City Park, New York \u2014 December 2016 to January 2017 Documented
The L.A. Fitness Center on Jericho Turnpike in Garden City Park, New York \u2014 in Nassau County \u2014 lost its pool and spa not to a voluntary closure but to a health commissioner’s order, and then spent more than a month proving it deserved them back.
The record, as reported from Nassau County Department of Health statements:
- One \u2014 and possibly two \u2014 cases of Legionnaires’ disease were attributed to the gym in late 2016.
- On December 30, 2016, Dr. Lawrence Eisenstein, Nassau County’s health commissioner, ordered the pool and spa closed after testing confirmed the areas contained significant amounts of Legionella pneumophila.
- A month later, on January 26, 2017, the pool and spa remained closed, with no reopening date. County health spokesperson Mary Ellen Laurain stated the order would not be lifted until the club showed sufficient evidence the pool was safe and met all the criteria the county had set forth.
Source: Pritzker Hageman, Jan 26, 2017 (reporting Nassau County Department of Health statements; the underlying news report is Athletic Business’s “Pool Remains Off Limits After Legionnaires Discovery,” January 2017).
What this page does not hold, and does not invent: the street number on Jericho Turnpike, the identities or outcomes of the attributed case(s) beyond what is stated above, and the eventual reopening date. The page will be updated by dated snapshot if the primary county record is pulled.
Why this one matters
Garden City Park completes a New York bookend to this chain’s Illinois files. In Naperville (2013\u201314), a county shut a hot tub that tested positive and reopened it after clearance testing. In Niles (2023), state testing confirmed Legionella in the hot tub and the whole wet wing closed. Here, the instrument was blunter and stronger: a commissioner’s order with the burden of proof reversed \u2014 the club did not get its pool back by announcing a cleaning; it got it back, whenever it did, by showing the county evidence against criteria the county set. That reversal \u2014 operator proves safe, instead of members proving harm \u2014 is the entire regulatory argument of this site in one county order.
All three locations belong to the same parent: LA Fitness clubs are company-owned, with no franchising, by Fitness International \u2014 so in each case the counterparty behind the local door is the parent itself.
Legionella is a bacterium, not a mold; it is tracked here because pools, spas, showers, and steam rooms are the same wet systems. For the disease itself, see Legionnaires’ disease, in plain English.
If this happened to you
Used a gym whose hot tub, sauna, or steam room looked \u2014 or smelled \u2014 neglected? File a report and put a date on it.
Trying to leave this gym? Joining took minutes online; leaving is its own fight — no cancel button, voicemail walls, a billing company, and a collector. That pipeline is documented step by step in The Gym Trap. In Florida, the exit is written into state law: How to Cancel a Gym in Florida (Fla. Stat. §501.017) — including the disability cancellation and the written-notice rule that terminates your obligation to any collector the gym handed your contract to.